Su Fan,Yang Heying,Yue Ming,et al.Clinical efficacies of congenital anorectal malformation with rectovestibular fistula in girls: a Meta-analysis[J].Journal of Clinical Pediatric Surgery,2022,21(10):958-967.[doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202110006-011]
先天性肛门闭锁伴直肠前庭瘘经肛穴肛门成形术与矢状入路肛门成形术后近期及远期并发症的Meta分析
- Title:
- Clinical efficacies of congenital anorectal malformation with rectovestibular fistula in girls: a Meta-analysis
- Keywords:
- Anorectal Malformations; Surgery; Anus; Imperforate; Surgery; Treatment Outcome; Infant; Newborn
- 摘要:
- 目的 运用Meta分析方法评价经肛穴肛门成形术(anal dimple anorectoplasty,ADARP)、前矢状入路肛门成形术(anterior sagittal anorectoplasty,ASARP)、后矢状入路肛门成形术(posterior sagittal anorectoplasty,PSARP)治疗先天性肛门闭锁伴直肠前庭瘘的临床效果。方法 计算机检索万方数据库、中国知网等中文数据库(检索式:直肠前庭瘘、肛门前庭瘘、前庭瘘、舟状窝瘘)和PubMed、Web of Science等英文数据库(检索式:vestibular fistula,rectovestibular fistula,anovestibular fistula),收集2002-2020年公开发表的关于ASARP、PSARP、ADARP治疗先天性肛门闭锁伴直肠前庭瘘的文献。通过阅读文献标题及摘要进行初步筛查,再进行二次筛选。用Stata 13.0对文献数据进行Meta分析,主要包括术后近期并发症(伤口感染、伤口裂开、直肠回缩、肛门狭窄、直肠脱垂和瘘口复发)和远期并发症(便秘和污粪)的发生率。结果 共纳入文献21篇,有效病例数776例。其中行ADARP术式4篇,ASARP术式8篇,PSARP术式11篇。ADARP术式分别在以下方面优于其他两种术式:切口感染发生率(ADARP:4%,95%CI:-0.02~0.10;ASARP:17%,95%CI:0.11~0.22;PSARP:9%,95%CI:0.04~0.14)、直肠回缩发生率(ADARP:4%,95%CI:-0.02~0.09;ASARP:5%,95%CI:0.01~0.10;PSARP:4%,95%CI:-0.04~0.13);直肠脱垂发生率(ADARP:4%,95%CI:-0.04~0.11;ASARP:8%,95%CI:0.03~0.13;PSARP:8%,95%CI:0.05~0.12);术后便秘发生率[ADARP:8%(95%CI:-0.03~0.18)、ASARP:18%(95%CI:0.10~0.26)、PSARP:17%(95%CI:0.10~0.23)];污粪发生率[ADARP 4%(95%CI:-0.04~0.11)、ASARP 13%(95%CI:0.05~0.21)、PSARP 17%(95%CI:0.10~0.25)]。在减少肛门狭窄及瘘口复发上,ADARP稍逊于其他两种术式。结论 与前矢状入路肛门成形术和后矢状入路肛门成形术相比,经肛穴肛门成形术治疗先天性肛门闭锁伴直肠前庭瘘术后切口感染、直肠回缩、直肠脱垂以及远期并发症的发生率较低,但肛门狭窄以及瘘口复发发生率稍高。
- Abstract:
- Objective To evaluate the surgical efficacy of anal dimple anorectoplasty (ADARP),anterior sagittal anorectoplasty (ASARP) and posterior sagittal anorectoplasty (PSARP) for congenital anorectal malformation with rectovestibular fistula through a Meta-analysis.Methods From 2002 to 2020,a literature search was performed within the databases of Wanfang,CNKI,PubMed and Web of Science regarding the treatment of congenital anorectal malformation with rectovestibular fistula by ASARP,PSARP and ADARP.Meta-analysis of literature data was performed with Stata 13.0,including the incidence of short-term postoperative complications (wound infection,wound dehiscence,rectal retraction,anal stricture,rectal prolapse & fistula recurrence) and long-term complications (constipation and soiling).Results In the end,a total of 21 articles with 776 effective cases were retrieved.There were ADARP(n=4),ASARP (n=8) and PSARP (n=11).ADARP was superior to the other two in the following aspects:incidence of wound infection [ADARP:4%,95%CI:-0.02 to 0.10;ASARP:17%,95%CI:0.11 to 0.22;PSARP:9%,95%CI:0.04-0.14],incidence of rectal retraction[ADARP:4%,95%CI:-0.02-0.09;ASARP:5%,95%CI:0.01-0.10;PSARP:4%,95%CI:-0.04-0.13],incidence of rectal prolapse [ADARP:4%,95%CI:-0.04-0.11;ASARP:8%,95%CI:0.03-0.13;PSARP:8%,95%CI:0.05-0.12];incidence of postoperative constipation[ADARP:8%(95%CI:-0.03-0.18),ASARP:18% (95%CI:0.10-0.26),PSARP:17% (95%CI:0.10-0.23)],incidence of soiling[ADARP 4% (95%CI:-0.04-0.11),ASARP 13% (95%CI:0.05-0.21),PSARP 17% (95%CI:0.10-0.25)].For the occurrence of anal stenosis and fistula recurrence,ADARP is slightly inferior to the other two procedures.Conclusion As compared with anterior and posterior sagittal anoplasty,anal dimple anorectoplasty is efficacious for congenital anal atresia with rectovestibular fistula postoperative incision infection,rectal retraction,rectal prolapse and distal complications.The incidence of early complications is lower.However,the incidence of anal stenosis and fistula recurrence has remained slightly higher.
参考文献/References:
[1] Levitt MA,Pe?a A.Anorectal malformations[J].Orphanet J Rare Dis,2007,2:33.DOI:10.1186/1750-1172-2-33.
[2] Khalifa M,Shreef K,Al Ekrashy MA,et al.One or two stages procedure for repair of rectovestibular fistula:which is safer?(A single institution experience)[J].Afr J Paediatr Surg,2017,14(2):27-31.DOI:10.4103/ajps.AJPS_61_16.
[3] Wang C,Li L,Liu S,et al.The management of anorectal malformation with congenital vestibular fistula:a single-stage modified anterior sagittal anorectoplasty[J].Pediatr Surg Int,2015,31(9):809-814.DOI:10.1007/s00383-015-3749-1.
[4] 白玉作.关注肛门直肠畸形的远期随访和多中心研究[J].中华小儿外科杂志,2018,39(12):881-882.DOI:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0253-3006.2018.12.001.Bai YZ.Long-term follow-up and multicenter study of anorectal malformations in children[J].China J Pediatr Surg,2018,39(12):881-882.DOI:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0253-3006.2018.12.001.
[5] Danielson J,Karlbom U,Graf W,et al.Posterior sagittal anorectoplasty results in better bowel function and quality of life in adulthood than pull-through procedures[J].J Pediatr Surg,2015,50(9):1556-1559.DOI:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2015.02.004.
[6] Kulshrestha S,Kulshrestha M,Singh B,et al.Anterior sagittal anorectoplasty for anovestibular fistula[J].Pediatr Surg Int,2007,23(12):1191-1197.DOI:10.1007/s00383-007-2019-2.
[7] Mitul AR,Ferdous KM,Shahjahan M,et al.Trans-fistula anorectoplasty (TFARP):our experience in the management of anorectovestibular fistula in neonates[J].J Neonatal Surg,2012,1(3):36.
[8] 李亚萍,杨合英,李延安,等.经肛穴肛门成形术治疗女婴肛门闭锁直肠前庭瘘的效果[J].郑州大学学报(医学版),2019,54(4):634-637.DOI:10.13705/j.issn.1671-6825.2018.11.046.Li YP,Yang HY,Li YA,et al.Efficacy of transanal acupoint anorectoplasty for female neonates with anal atresia and rectovestibular fistula[J].Journal of Zhengzhou University (Medical Sciences),2019,54(4):634-637.DOI:10.13705/j.issn.1671-6825.2018.11.046.
[9] Slim K,Nini E,Forestier D,et al.Methodological index for non-randomized studies (minors):development and validation of a new instrument[J].ANZ J Surg,2003,73(9):712-716.DOI:10.1046/j.1445-2197.2003.02748.x.
[10] Hashizume N,Asagiri K,Fukahori S,et al.Functional assessment of the patients with perineal and vestibular fistula treated by anterior sagittal anorectoplasty[J].Afr J Paediatr Surg,2018,15(1):36-41.DOI:10.4103/ajps.AJPS_91_17.
[11] Upadhyaya VD,Gopal SC,Gupta DK,et al.Single stage repair of anovestibular fistula in neonate[J].Pediatr Surg Int,2007,23(8):737-740.DOI:10.1007/s00383-007-1965-z.
[12] Harjai MM,Sethi N,Chandra N.Anterior sagittal anorectoplasty:An alternative to posterior approach in management of congenital vestibular fistula[J].Afr J Paediatr Surg,2013,10(2):78-82.DOI:10.4103/0189-6725.115027.
[13] 孙小兵,李健,代晋宇.前矢状入路肛门成形术治疗肛门闭锁直肠前庭瘘的疗效评价[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2018,17(10):763-768.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1671-6353.2018.10.009.Sun XB,Li J,Dai JY.Evaluation of anterior sagittal anoplasty for anorectal malformation with rectovestibular fistula[J].J Clin Ped Sur,2018,17(10):763-768.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1671-6353.2018.10.009.
[14] Negm M,Arafa M,Elshimy K.Short-term outcome of one-stage sphincter-saving anterior sagittal anorectoplasty in vestibular and perineal fistulae in female infants[J].The Egyptian Journal of Surgery,2020,39(1):199-205.DOI:10.4103/ejs.ejs_171_19.
[15] Amanollahi O,Ketabchian S.One-stage vs.three-stage repair in anorectal malformation with rectovestibular fistula[J].Afr J Paediatr Surg,2016,13(1):20-25.DOI:10.4103/0189-6725.181702.
[16] Julià V,Tarrado X,Prat J,et al.Fifteen years of experience in the treatment of anorectal malformations[J].Pediatr Surg Int,2010,26(2):145-149.DOI:10.1007/s00383-009-2497-5.
[17] Hassett S,Snell S,Hughes-Thomas A,et al.10-year outcome of children born with anorectal malformation,treated by posterior sagittal anorectoplasty,assessed according to the Krickenbeck classification[J].J Pediatr Surg,2009,44(2):399-403.DOI:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2008.10.092.
[18] Upadhyaya VD,Gangopadhyay AN,Pandey A,et al.Single-stage repair for rectovestibular fistula without opening the fourchette[J].J Pediatr Surg,2008,43(4):775-779.DOI:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2007.11.038.
[19] Nam SH,Kim DY,Kim SC.Can we expect a favorable outcome after surgical treatment for an anorectal malformation?[J].J Pediatr Surg,2016,51(3):421-424.DOI:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2015.08.048.
[20] Karakus SC,User IR,Akcaer V,et al.Posterior sagittal anorectoplasty in vestibular fistula:with or without colostomy[J].Pediatr Surg Int,2017,33(7):755-759.DOI:10.1007/s00383-017-4102-7.
[21] Kigo CN,Ndung’u JM.Bowel function following primary repair of anorectal malformations at Kenyatta National Hospital[J].East Afr Med J,2002,79(3):124-127.DOI:10.4314/eamj.v79i3.8889.
[22] 李小卫,卢应酬,王坤,等.不同手术方式治疗无肛前庭瘘疗效比较[J].中国医药科学,2017,7(8):210-212.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.2095-0616.2017.08.066.Li XW,Lu YC,Wang K,et al.Therapeutic comparison of different surgical methods in the treatment of aproctia vestibular Fistula[J].China Medicine and Pharmacy,2017,7(8):210-212.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.2095-0616.2017.08.066.
[23] Liem NT,Quynh TA.One stage operation through modified posterior sagittal approach preserving the sphincter intact for anal agenesis with rectovestibular fistula[J].J Pediatr Surg,2015,50(4):634-637.DOI:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2015.01.003.
[24] 黄焱磊,沈淳,郑珊,等.改良Pe?a术一期根治肛门闭锁伴直肠前庭瘘的疗效分析[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2020,19(10):897-902.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1671-6353.2020.10.007.Huang YL,Shen C,Zheng S,et al.Analysis of curative effect of modified Pena operation for one-stage radical treatment of anal atresia with rectal vestibular fistula[J].J Clin Ped Sur,2020,19(10):897-902.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1671-6353.2020.10.007.
[25] 白强,李传新,颜剑宏,等.肛门成形瘘口修补术治疗先天性肛门闭锁伴直肠舟状窝会阴瘘[J].云南医药,2018,39(6):519-520,529.Bai Q,Li CX,Yan JH,et al.Anoplasty and fistula repair in the treatment of congenital anal atresia with rectal navicular fossa-perineal fistula[J].Medicine and Pharmacy of Yunnan,2018,39(6):519-520,529.
[26] 陶强,徐本源,徐维,等.会阴肛门成形同期内瘘修补治疗无肛并直肠舟状窝瘘[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2002,1(2):104-105,97.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1671-6353.2002.02.008.Tao Q,Xu BY,Xu W,et al.In Combination of Perineum-anoplasty and Internal Fistula Repairment Simultaneous Applied to Treat the Congenital Non-anus Complicated with Rectal Navicular Fossa Fistula[J].J Clin Ped Sur,2002,1(2):104-105,97.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1671-6353.2002.02.008.
[27] 李荣先,李相臣,彭昕.先天性肛门闭锁并舟状窝瘘22例[J].中国肛肠病杂志,2011,31(11):54-55.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-1174.2011.11.031.Li RX,Li XC,Peng X.Experience on the 22 pediatric patients with congenital anal atresia associated with navicula fistula[J].Chinese Journal of Coloproctology,2011,31(11):54-55.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-1174.2011.11.031.
[28] Belizon A,Levitt M,Shoshany G,et al.Rectal prolapse following posterior sagittal anorectoplasty for anorectal malformations[J].J Pediatr Surg,2005,40(1):192-196.DOI:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2004.09.035.
[29] Bischoff A.The surgical treatment of cloaca[J].Semin Pediatr Surg,2016,25(2):102-107.DOI:10.1053/j.sempedsurg.2015.11.009.
[30] Wilkie G,Bartz D.Vaginal rejuvenation:a review of female genital cosmetic surgery[J].Obstet Gynecol Surv,2018,73(5):287-292.DOI:10.1097/OGX.0000000000000559.
[31] Minneci PC,Kabre RS,Mak GZ,et al.Can fecal continence be predicted in patients born with anorectal malformations?[J].J Pediatr Surg,2019,54(6):1159-1163.DOI:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2019.02.035.
[32] 陈强谱,冀海斌,魏强.加速康复外科理念下围手术期营养管理[J].中华普通外科学文献(电子版),2018,12(5):289-291.DOI:10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-0793.2018.05.001.Chen QP,Jin HB,Wei Q.Nutritional management during perioperative period under the concept of enhanced recovery after surgery[J].Chinese Archives of General Surgery (Electronic Edition),2018,12(5):289-291.DOI:10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-0793.2018.05.001.
[33] 梁燕芳,赖伟红.先天性肛门闭锁患儿肛门成形术后扩肛治疗的护理[J].中国肛肠病杂志,2017,37(10):63-65.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-1174.2017.10.032.Liang YF,Lai WH.Nursing for anal dilatation after anoplasty for congenital anal atresia in children[J].Chinese Journal of Coloproctology,2017,37(10):63-65.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-1174.2017.10.032.
相似文献/References:
[1]刘平波,王敬华,曾德斌,等.微创手术矫治漏斗胸125例[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2008,7(03):8.
[2]曹永胜,窦莹,蔡盈,等.改良Snodrass手术一期修复小儿尿道下裂25例[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2008,7(03):16.
[3]孙文丽,周薇莉,周玉玲,等.一期Pena肛门成形治疗婴儿中间位无肛7例[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2008,7(03):31.
[4]谢向辉,黄澄如,孙宁,等.小儿先天性肾盂输尿管连接部梗阻诊治265例[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2008,7(06):13.
[5]丁波,彭立君.肱骨髁上骨折增加外固定时间的疗效观察[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2007,6(04):35.
[6]周智恩 冯君 熊霞霞 孙小圣 陈红英 杜娟 王道庄 邓硕曾. 小儿法乐四联症围术期的治疗策略[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2012,11(01):13.
[7]汤绍涛,张梦欣,池水清.肛门直肠畸形外科治疗前沿:机器人手术现状及未来趋势[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2022,21(11):1001.[doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202210006-001]
Tang Shaotao,Zhang Mengxin,Chi Shuiqing.Frontiers in surgical treatment of anorectal malformations: current status and future trend of robotic-assisted surgery[J].Journal of Clinical Pediatric Surgery,2022,21(10):1001.[doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202210006-001]
[8]朱中贤,唐维兵.先天性肛门直肠畸形基础研究的进展与展望[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2022,21(11):1006.[doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202210017-002]
Zhu Zhongxian,Tang Weibing.Recent advances and future prospects of basic researches on congenital anorectal malformations[J].Journal of Clinical Pediatric Surgery,2022,21(10):1006.[doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202210017-002]
[9]李薇,汪飞,林刚,等.肛门直肠畸形合并先天性脊柱畸形的临床及影像学特征分析[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2022,21(11):1012.[doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202209024-003]
Li Wei,Wang Fei,Lin Gang,et al.Clinical and radiological characteristics of congenital spinal deformity associated with anorectal malformation-[J].Journal of Clinical Pediatric Surgery,2022,21(10):1012.[doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202209024-003]
[10]王哲,谢晓丽,何秋明,等.腹腔镜泌尿生殖窦分离术辅助治疗复杂泄殖腔畸形的临床应用[J].临床小儿外科杂志,2022,21(11):1019.[doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202205074-004]
Wang Zhe,Xie Xiaoli,He Qiuming,et al.Laparoscopic separation of urogenital sinus in intractable cloaca[J].Journal of Clinical Pediatric Surgery,2022,21(10):1019.[doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202205074-004]
备注/Memo
收稿日期:2021-10-10。
通讯作者:杨合英,Email:yanghy130@163.com